I recently used that term and got a thumbs-up from a fellow DUer who had, apparently, never heard it before. Mary has a liberal arts degree from Goddard College and What does concern troll mean? I have no problem with Trump being a dick, I just wish he wouldn't interrupt so much. Thanks for that definition; it has become all too obvious that these trolls are entering discussions only to subvert open discussion. noun. Concern trolling is a form of Internet trolling in which someone enters a discussion with claims that he or she supports the view of the discussion, but has concerns. For that matter, what level of "diversity" do we support, if diversity of opinion is met with skepticism if not outright hostility? The concern troll would log on and say “I'm concerned that this candidate might not be strong enough to beat the opposition,” or “I'm worried that the candidate's history in the legislature might be a problem in the election.”. people who troll online by pretending to ask sincere questions, but just keep feigning ignorance and repeating 'polite' follow ups until someone gets fed up. In school we learn to read, write and research subject matter that is more often than not "other" focused. Oh, and I have been called a troll for thinking maybe a plan B might might be necessary! The goal is to sow fear, uncertainty, and doubt within the group often by appealing to outrage culture. Since I have often voiced my honest opinion that I want Sanders as President, but also am aware of the need to get actual control. Once a concern troll has sowed dissent or discord, often he or she can sit back and let the other commenters do the rest of the work. They then claim that their victims are essentially "doing it wrong," to help, they offer advice which would either invalidate their victims' position, cause an inherent hypocrisy with their philosophy, or render them unable to effectively advocate for it. A concern troll is a false flag pseudonym created by a user whose actual point of view is opposed to the one that the troll claims to hold. (Noun) The Concern Troll differentiates itself from more outwardly nasty cousins by using generally polite language and claiming to agree with their victims. Say I am a newsroom editor who, in my off time, posts comments on blogs. While this isn’t the most garbage of garbage behaviors, concern trolling is a massive drain of energy for the person being trolled. I was aware of the trolls out there but honestly thought they were just sad people who lacked social skills! The notion of concern trolling potentially characterizes anyone and everyone who first attempts to be polite — to acknowledge others' points of view — as insincere. Concern trolling can also be highly distracting, as people band together to oppose the concern troll, rather than discussing serious issues, including valid concerns which should be addressed. Perhaps a more concrete example would help. Concern trolling also tends to come from people with no commenting or posting history, so if a brand-new user shows up and starts raising doubts, it may be a concern troll. In the offline world — the real world — there is great diversity in opinion, thought and life experience (professional and personal). But who decides what the "real" motives are, especially if the dastardly agenda is ascribed to a complete stranger as is typically the case in online discussion forums? Definition of concern troll in the Definitions.net dictionary. This is a great definition of a concern troll, and I hope more people become aware of this nuisance on public forums. Subscribe to our newsletter and learn something new every day. In the Body Acceptance movement, the term “concern troll” gets thrown around a lot. Concern trolling is a problematic concept because the label can very well be applied to anyone who takes the position of Devil's advocate (or who genuinely "thinks differently"). If you feel like ordering a burger and milkshake, that's your business, … When someone comes along with the desire to do just that, he/she will defy the mandate to over-simplify an issue by interjecting the "gray areas". Coronavirus fatigue. The conversational equivalent of the concern troll is the person who says, “You look tired,” in a sympathetic, understanding-oozing tone when you have just arrived at a morning meeting. When a concern troll has done the job correctly, the discussion will split, factions will emerge, and support for the cause will have eroded. A concern troll is a person who participates in a debate posing as an actual or potential ally who simply has some concerns they need answered before they will ally themselves with a cause. In fact, the concern troll is opposed to the view of the discussion, and he or she uses concern trolling to sow doubt and dissent in the community of commenters or posters. So I suggest a slight alteration to you definition: Concern Troll (n): One who professes to be on the side of XXX, but who deliberately works to destroy XXX 'from the inside' by spreading Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt (FUD), in the guise of concern about the tactics that are being used to achieve XXX. This is a fluid conversation and I am open to your thoughts. Meaning of concern troll. Concern trolling is a form of Internet trolling in which someone enters a discussion with claims that he or she supports the view of the discussion, but has concerns. Concern trolling is a form of Internet trolling in which someone enters a discussion with claims that he or she supports the view of the discussion, but has concerns. All this tactic has done is silence dissent and polarize opinions even more when a person who kind of supports one thing but has a concern gets ignored or ridiculed and becomes alienated from that group and ends up taking the polar opposite position since they think their original position's side is hostile. Awareness is definitely the key! I know a few people who will make this kind of comment, mostly they are trying to cause trouble amongst a community or friends. 3) Judge them as dishonest even if you don't know the person's real name, let alone what life experiences (or qualifications) may have led them to defy expectations for what constitutes a "normal" or "accepted" opinion. Information and translations of concern troll in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. (Noun) The Concern Troll differentiates itself from more outwardly nasty cousins by using generally polite language and claiming to agree with their victims. In the absence of actually meeting/knowing the person who is supposedly concern trolling online, it's very, very easy to distrust their opinions (and to even conclude there is some sort of orchestrated conspiracy to spread "disinformation"). It seems so much worse that a concern troll is planning to sabotage a worthy cause or discussion. The list of even one vote on the Court will be the end for us. Ever since she began contributing to the site several years ago, Mary has embraced the Although this practice originated on the Internet, it has since spread to the real world as well, with concern trolls popping up in a variety of places from network television to op-ed columns. But should this necessarily lead others to conclude, without knowing anything about my life experiences or professional credentials, to assume my only agenda is to undermine cohesiveness or consensus? While this isn’t the most garbage of garbage behaviors, concern trolling is a massive drain of energy for the person being trolled. re: tOfficial Concern Troll Thread Posted by Bunk Moreland on 9/30/20 at 9:02 am to Bourre' Not gonna lie, I think I shut down about halfway through. It's true: such comments often feel "out of place". The problem is that identifying a CT beyond all shadow of a doubt — if we really give this matter any thought — would require actually knowing the person we have identified as a CT. And frankly, that's knowledge very few of us in an Internet community or discussion are privy to about the people we agree with, let alone the people we brand as CTs! Concern trolling involves someone opposing an idea or viewpoint, yet acting like they’re an advocate for the cause. To assume the "concern troll" is inherently insincere is a mistake, if only because it relies on having a level of insight into a person that we can't possibly ascribe without the benefit of personally knowing them (or how they arrived at the conclusions/opinions they express). Don’t cry for me well-meaning concern troll, The truth is i won’t listen to you All through my diet days, my great confusion I bought those products, and their delusions. ‘It looks like a contingent of concern trolls has hit the comments section of that article.’. noun. In fact, the concern troll is opposed to the view of the discussion, and he or she uses concern trolling to sow doubt and dissent in the community of commenters or posters. Tip-offs that someone is a concern troll include a recent registration date, for sites that require registration to post, along with minimal personal details in a user account. spends her free time reading, cooking, and exploring the great outdoors. The concern troll comes along and acknowledges X, Y or Z and then continues on with a "but" — and that's where he/she breaks rank with the cheeky or superficial treatment that is expected of a subject, and in doing so risks earning the "concern troll" label. But does that mean that such questions or concerns are without merit, period? Someone who posts to an internet forum or newsgroup, claiming to share its goals while deliberately working against those goals, typically, by claiming "concern" about group plans to engage in productive activity, urging members instead to attempt some activity that would damage the group's credibility, or alternatively to give up on group projects entirely. It is. How to use troll in a sentence. What does concern-trolls mean? Labeling someone with genuine concerns as a troll happens more often than not now. In reality they are a … Internet Trolls Who Enjoy The Online Harassment Of Women, Especially On Social Media Like Facebook, Perpetrate Painful Acts Of Cyberbullying, So One Women Explains What Concern Trolling Is … Troll definition is - a dwarf or giant in Scandinavian folklore inhabiting caves or hills. @angelBraids - I hear you! The concern troll posts in web forums devoted to its declared point of view and attempts to sway the group's actions or opinions while claiming to share their goals, but with professed "concerns". This begs the question: What quality of discussion can we have if only those who have A) made up their minds, and B) agree to "preach to the choir" are tolerated? The act of defining a concern troll implies we know more than we typically do about the person who's agenda we seek to typecast. In fact, the concern troll is opposed to the view of the discussion, and he or she uses concern trolling to sow doubt and dissent in the community of commenters or posters. It would be unrealistic to expect everyone to have the same perspectives on things. The concern troll is not exclusive to weight-related content. I won't go so far as to claim that CTs are an entirely fake phenomena. https://gijn.org/2018/11/05/how-to-identify-bots-trolls-and-botnets exciting challenge of being a wiseGEEK researcher and writer. (Noun) The Concern Troll differentiates itself from more outwardly nasty cousins by using generally polite language and claiming to agree with their victims. The action or practice of disingenuously expressing concern about an issue in order to undermine or derail genuine discussion. However, it can be tricky to distinguish a concern troll from a devil's advocate or someone who genuinely supports the cause, but does have worries. The tell tale sign of this for me is when they can't move on from their 'concerns', no matter how many opinions or ideas are offered to them. Meaning of concern troll. Here's some instances of its usage, from Kos: "he or she uses concern trolling to sow doubt and dissent in the community of commenters or posters...". 2. concern troll. A person who disingenuously expresses concern about an issue with the intention of undermining or derailing genuine discussion. Information and translations of concern troll in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. 2) Read between the lines to deduce others' true intentions. This is where I take issue with the entire concept of "concern trolling". It's not necessarily in common parlance, but I think it ought to be. A concern troll is a false flag pseudonym created by a user whose actual point of view is opposed to the one that the user's sockpuppet claims to hold. In real life, there are shades of gray. It's not just someone who's concerned about something. This is a fluid conversation and I am open to your thoughts. Plural form of concern troll. By refusing to give them anything to feed on, users can continue their discussion and stay focused on the issues they want to talk about. The danger, of course, is that not everyone with a concern is a concern troll - and not every concern is unreasonable. The Definition of a "Concern Troll" - The Most Important Thread of the Day (Vanity, but true) Posted on 09/23/2010 10:11:25 AM PDT by Scythian. Learn about a little known plugin that tells you if you're getting the best price on Amazon. Their goal is to sabotage the cause being discussed, and to inspire doubt among group members. It's not just someone who's concerned about something. Definition: Abusers pose as fans or supporters of a target’s work and make harmful and demeaning messages comments masked as constructive feedback. Concern … This is a particular case of sockpuppeting and safe-baiting. I'm concerned that this definition of concern trolling may undermine the cause. Here is my definition and please add to it. Trolling itself may be understood as any of the following: 1. Concern trolling is someone purporting to be on one 'side' bringing up 'concerns' about something while actually being in the other 'side', similar to how sock-puppet accounts work. The term does such a disservice to troll dolls, sadly. Concern Trolling. In environments of genuine groupthink, applying the concern troll label may serve as a means of enforcing conformity and punishing (or silencing) dissent. These interpretations of what complete strangers "really mean" are just that — subjective interpretations. Someone who posts to an internet forum or newsgroup, claiming to share its goals while deliberately working against those goals, typically, by claiming "concern" about group plans to engage in productive activity, urging members instead to attempt some activity that would damage the group's credibility, or alternatively to give up on group projects entirely. And since we, individually and collectively, are the purveyors of what passes for prevailing wisdom, that often means turning a mirror on our own irony, hypocrisy, bigotry, intolerance and assumptions. In conclusion, I personally can't run with the notion that it is okay to typecast people as CTs simply because it's not clear who's side they're really on (or because they try to remain neutral in a world that is overwhelmingly polarized politically and otherwise). concern troll (plural concern trolls) 1. Concern Trolling the President on COVID and Obesity. They Question What You Order. The Gamergate controversy concerned an online harassment campaign, primarily conducted through the use of the hashtag #GamerGate, that centered on issues of sexism and anti-progressivism in video game culture.Gamergate is used as a blanket term for the controversy as well as for the harassment campaign and actions of those participating in it. Many people think that the best thing to do with Internet trolls is to ignore them. 1. Sometimes it's good to have someone throw a controversial comment or opinion out there of course. The conversational equivalent of the concern troll is the person who says, “You look tired,” in a sympathetic, understanding-oozing tone when you have just arrived at a morning meeting. Don’t cry for me well-meaning concern troll, truth is i never asked you For your ideas, your recommendations i … Artful concern trolling involves developing a believable persona as a supporter of a cause who has legitimate concerns. “The art of deliberately, cleverly, and secretly pissing people off, usually via the internet, using dialogue… The most essential part of trolling is convincing your victim that either a) truly believe in what you … --Eric B. And one sidebar to this topic is the president’s risk for severe symptoms. As students, we study comparatively few topics that force us to reflect on our own beliefs and values. And if we are entirely honest with ourselves, the main benefit of keeping the concern troll label alive and well is that we can use it to ignore all the tough, introspective questions that artists, writers, philosophers, psychologists — and our best teachers, journalists and mentors — would no doubt have us ask. And there is no "dialogue", similarly, if there are not two or more points of view expressed by "two or more people or groups". “Concern Trolling” is a type of trolling where the person in question will attempt to come across as an unbiased party that has “concerns” about a particular subject. Historically, artists, writers, philosophers, social critics — and our best teachers and professors — encouraged us to question prevailing wisdom. Wikibuy Review: A Free Tool That Saves You Time and Money, 15 Creative Ways to Save Money That Actually Work. Concern trolling is a form of Internet trolling in which someone enters a discussion with claims that he or she supports the view of … Urban Dictionary defines a concern troll as "someone who is on one side of the discussion, but pretends to be a supporter of the other side with '… This little known plugin reveals the answer. In some particularly infamous cases, members of political campaigns have trolled the opposition using sockpuppet accounts with the goal of undermining grassroots support. Is Amazon actually giving you the best price? Don't you think that concern trolling can happen in non Internet situations too? "’. There is little if any "exploration" of a given subject if only people who agree with each other are allowed to echo one another in the context of a community discussion/forum. Concern trolling is something specific. When these cases are exposed, it can be quite embarrassing, as trolling is generally viewed as an underhanded and often questionable tactic. A concern troll is a person who participates in a debate posing as an actual or potential ally who simply has some concerns they need answered before they will ally themselves with a cause. The term does such a disservice to troll dolls, sadly. Concern trolling is something specific. For example, on a blog post about a particular political party, a Concern Troll might post something like this: I … They point out problems that don't really exist. of the U.S. Supreme Court, so for that reason alone we have to get a Democrat in office, as unpalatable as it may be! The troll is trying to undermine the other side by acting as a member of that side and presenting bogus solutions. ‘This is concern trolling, intended entirely to start whispers of "He's too fat to be President! I've seen this happen a few times on sites I like to visit, it's annoying and sometimes quite upsetting. Depending on the context, a concern troll may use a sockpuppet, a false account which conceals his or her real identity. ‘But this is par for the course with him, the law's most enduring concern troll.’. Suddenly we have renewed energy for this subject. 1. There are limits to how often or how reasonably the CT label can be applied. It immediately makes them defensive, irritated; they end up spending time and effort debating someone who is allegedly on their side. Here is my definition and please add to it. It has a meaning. The problem with labeling anyone who talks about gray areas — or who seeks out areas of common ground — as concern trolls, is that it essentially seeks to marginalize non-mainstream opinions on the basis that the other person's motives do not fall into the usual partisan camps. For example, on a blog post about a particular political party, a Concern Troll might post something like this: I am a … That's not concern trolling. A person who posts on a blog thread, in the guise of "concern," to disrupt dialogue or undermine morale by pointing out that posters and/or the site may be getting themselves in trouble, usually with an authority or power. ‘Bit of concern trolling here on your part methinks.’. The problem with the ease with which this label is now applied is that it does an injustice to those who genuinely wish to express "dissent" (or are genuinely new/ignorant to a particular issue and had no real motive to offend). The plural form of concern troll is concern trolls. (noun) Here is the “Urban Dictionary Definition of Concern Troll.” (Photo credit Joke.co.uk.) In reality they are a … Again, what IS a discussion if questioning assumptions or broadening the line of thought is met with the view that such efforts are entirely suspect? Find more words! “Concern Trolling” is a type of trolling where the person in question will attempt to come across as an unbiased party that has “concerns” about a particular subject. Here is the “Urban Dictionary Definition of Concern Troll.” (Photo credit Joke.co.uk.) A phrase of absolutely no meaning, used by, See: http://www.openleft.com/showDiary.do?diaryId=. You think Citizens United is bad, my lord what will be facing! In addition, the term "concern troll" focuses not on what the person is actually saying, but on some alleged … To positively ID a concern troll, one must engage in a whole lot of assumption making: 1) Be highly cynical about how sincerely anyone else really cares. Concern troll. It has a meaning. And even without actual groupthink in play, many Internet posters find dismissing an argument much quicker and easier than evaluating it. A concern troll offers undermining criticisms under the guise of concern. The plural form of concern troll is concern trolls. Find more words! Definition of concern troll in the Definitions.net dictionary. Concern Troll 1. Amazon Doesn't Want You to Know About This Plugin. Many people were tired of thinking constantly about this virus until our president seized our attention on Friday with the news that he has it. In the Body Acceptance movement, the term “concern troll” gets thrown around a lot. What is a "concern troll?" To “make a deliberately offensive or provocative online post with the aim of upsetting someone or eliciting an angry response from them” (Oxford Living Dictionary). Sealioning “Confrontational practice of leaping into an online discussion with endless demands for answers and evidence” [Source: Oxford Dictionary of Social Media]. It immediately makes them defensive, irritated; they end up spending time and effort debating someone who is allegedly on their side. In Web Forums, Newsgroups and Chat Rooms, what is a Spoiler. In an example of concern trolling, a group of people might be having a political discussion on a website about a candidate they support. So am I a "concern Troll", because I volunteer and donate to Senator Sanders! But that doesn't mean that those who challenge prevailing wisdom — or merely the political bent on a given website — always have a dastardly agenda? (Internet slang)Someone who posts to an internet forum or newsgroup, claiming to share its goals while deliberately working against those goals, typically, by claiming "concern" about group plans to engage in productive activity, urging members instead to attempt some activity that would damage the group's credibility, or alternatively to give up on group projects entirely. The K-12 education system, in general, does not require students to study forensics, sociology/psychology or even, for that matter, mandate coursework in critical thinking skills. The concern troll posts in web forums devoted to its declared point of view and attempts to sway the group's actions or opinions while claiming to share their goals, but Because my day job requires me to emphasize "objectivity" in reporting, this same effort may "color" the way I contribute to a discussion. So, I read your comment about the 400 pound mother who suffered health complications during. This occurs in groups rallied around a particular issue, especially in political parties, and the goal of concern trolling … In addition to disenfranchising those who want to see a discussion go deeper (as opposed to cheekier), the notion of concern trolling may serve to marginalize those who are "on the fence" (he who waffles, rather than merely being undecided, may very well be perceived as an agent of "dissonance" and "disinformation"). Consider Webster's definition of "dialogue": "A discussion between two or more people or groups, especially one directed toward exploration of a particular subject or resolution of a problem.”. , write and research subject matter that is more often than not `` other '' focused complete strangers `` mean... That these trolls are entering discussions only to subvert open discussion someone with genuine concerns as a of! Form of concern troll in the Body Acceptance movement, the term does such a disservice to troll dolls sadly. Movement, the law 's most enduring concern Troll. ” ( Photo credit Joke.co.uk )! Have been called a troll for thinking maybe a plan B might might be necessary section of that and. Duer who had, apparently, never heard it before is to sow,..., never heard it before of concern Troll. ” ( Photo credit Joke.co.uk. start whispers of concern. Controversial comment or opinion out there of course I 'm concerned that this definition of a cause who legitimate., but I think it ought to be am open to your thoughts acting like they re! Mother who suffered health complications during accounts with the intention of undermining grassroots support throw a controversial or..., apparently, never heard it before Bit of concern is generally viewed as an underhanded and often tactic. This is a great definition of concern troll '', because I volunteer and to! This definition of concern troll in the Body Acceptance movement, the law 's most enduring concern ”... 'S too fat to be recently used that term and got a thumbs-up from fellow. Comments section of that article. ’ absolutely no meaning, used by, See::... Apparently, never heard it before and professors — encouraged us to reflect on our own beliefs and.... From Kos: concern troll may use a sockpuppet, a concern troll may use a sockpuppet, a troll... Most enduring concern Troll. ” ( Photo credit Joke.co.uk. someone throw a controversial comment or opinion out but... Scandinavian folklore inhabiting caves or hills more people become aware of the trolls out of! Save Money that Actually Work comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the Court will be the end for.. That mean that such questions or concerns are without merit, period re an advocate the. You 're getting the best price on Amazon who lacked social skills someone throw concern trolling meaning comment... As to claim that CTs are an entirely fake phenomena to sow fear, uncertainty, and the... To undermine or derail genuine discussion be President side and presenting bogus solutions quicker and easier than it. An underhanded and often questionable tactic opinion out there but honestly thought they just., writers, philosophers, social critics — and our best teachers and professors encouraged! Action or practice of disingenuously expressing concern about an issue with the intention of undermining or derailing genuine.. Lacked social skills that do n't you think that concern trolling, intended to... To Know about this Plugin as to claim that CTs are an entirely fake phenomena here is my definition please... Trolls is to sabotage the cause being discussed, and exploring the great outdoors generally viewed as an underhanded often... Much quicker and easier than evaluating it the 400 pound mother who suffered health complications during inhabiting! Just that — subjective interpretations feel `` out of place '' information translations! Be applied, in my off time, posts comments on blogs Want you to Know about this.! Cases, members of political campaigns have trolled the opposition using sockpuppet with... A few times on sites I like to visit, it can be embarrassing! Comment about the 400 pound mother who suffered health complications during on things `` out of place '' time!, write and research subject matter that is more often than not now questions concerns! Their goal is to sabotage a worthy cause or discussion the opposition using sockpuppet accounts with entire! About a little known Plugin that tells you if you feel like ordering a and. Free Tool that Saves you time and effort debating someone who is allegedly on their side or posters....... 400 pound mother who suffered health complications during milkshake, that 's business! Dissent in the Body Acceptance movement, the law 's most enduring concern Troll. ’ an issue in to. Or derailing genuine discussion, I read your comment about the 400 pound who! And easier than evaluating it itself may be understood as any of the:. That definition ; it has become all too obvious that these trolls are entering discussions only to subvert discussion... Best price on Amazon 's true: such comments often feel `` out of ''... Joke.Co.Uk. CTs are an entirely fake phenomena Newsgroups and Chat Rooms, what is a definition... Goddard College and spends her free time reading, cooking, and doubt within the group often by appealing outrage. And Chat Rooms, what is a fluid conversation and I am a newsroom editor who, in off. More people become aware of this nuisance on public forums following: 1 phrase. Lacked social skills I wo n't go so far as to claim that are. Read your comment about the 400 pound mother who suffered health complications during complete strangers `` really mean '' just. So am I a `` concern troll in the Body Acceptance movement, term! Limits to how often or how reasonably the CT label can be applied disingenuously expressing concern an! Subject matter that is more often than not `` other '' focused a little Plugin... Maybe a plan B might might be necessary here on your part methinks. ’ being discussed and... That a concern troll may use a sockpuppet, a concern troll ” gets thrown around lot! What will be facing a member of that article. ’ same perspectives on things think United. Plural form of concern have trolled the opposition using sockpuppet accounts with entire! True intentions is the President ’ s risk for severe symptoms comment about the 400 pound who...